In-Person vs. Virtual Therapy: A Clinical Comparison for Wisconsin Individuals & Couples
By the Shoreside Therapies clinical team · Milwaukee, Whitefish Bay & Glendale, WI
For most people, the choice between meeting a therapist in an office and meeting over video is less about which one "works" and more about which one fits your life, your concerns and, for couples, your relationship. Both formats are real therapy, delivered by the same licensed clinicians, with the same goals.
This guide compares in-person and virtual therapy for individuals and couples in Wisconsin. It covers what the research says, what actually changes in the room (or on the screen), when one format is the better starting point, and how costs, superbills and out-of-network benefits work at Shoreside Therapies for each.
Key Takeaways
- Research to date generally finds video-based therapy comparable to in-person care for many common concerns, such as anxiety and depression. The bigger factor is the fit between you and your therapist.
- Virtual couples therapy can work well, but it needs privacy, a shared screen and, in some situations (such as safety concerns), an in-person or individual-session start.
- At Shoreside, fees, superbills and HSA/FSA eligibility are the same whether you meet in Milwaukee, Whitefish Bay, Glendale or online.
The Short Answer: What Research Says
Telehealth therapy has been studied for more than two decades, and the body of evidence grew quickly after 2020. Systematic reviews generally find that video-based psychotherapy produces outcomes similar to in-person therapy for many common concerns, including depression, anxiety and stress-related problems.
Research on virtual couples therapy is smaller but growing. Studies so far suggest couples can build a strong working relationship with a therapist over video, which is one of the most consistent predictors of how therapy goes in any format.
That doesn't mean the formats are identical. Each one has practical strengths and limits, and the right choice depends on your situation. Everyone's needs and pace are different.
In-Person vs. Virtual Therapy: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | In-Person (Milwaukee, Whitefish Bay, Glendale) | Virtual (HIPAA-Compliant Video) |
|---|---|---|
| Who you see | Licensed clinician (LPC, LCSW) | The same licensed clinicians |
| Treatment approaches | CBT, EMDR, Brainspotting, Gottman-informed couples work and more | Most approaches adapt well. Some (like intensives) are in person only |
| Body language & nonverbal cues | Full view of posture, movement and the space between partners | Face and upper body. Camera setup matters |
| Travel & time | Commute plus session time | Session time only, from home, office or car (parked) |
| Privacy | A dedicated, confidential room | Depends on your space at home. Headphones help |
| Scheduling | Office hours at a specific location | Often more flexible, including lunch breaks |
| Couples logistics | Partners arrive and sit together | Partners can join from one room or, in some cases, two locations |
| Where you can be | Our three Wisconsin offices | Physically in Wisconsin, or a state where your clinician is licensed (couples: IL, MN, CO) |
| Cost & superbill | Same fees, superbill available | Same fees, superbill available |
How Online Individual Counseling Differs from In-Person
What stays the same
The core of therapy doesn't change on a screen: a trained clinician, a clear plan and a confidential conversation. Your therapist still completes an assessment, works with you on goals and adjusts the approach as you go.
Structured, skills-based approaches such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) translate especially well to video. CBT focuses on the links between thoughts, feelings and behaviors, and much of the work (thought records, behavioral experiments, practice between sessions) happens the same way online. Your therapist can share a worksheet on screen instead of handing it across a table.
What changes
- Less friction. No commute, parking or waiting room. For busy professionals and parents, that often makes it easier to show up consistently, and consistency matters.
- Your environment becomes part of the session. Some people open up more at home. Others find it hard to talk freely with family nearby. A closed door, headphones or a parked car can solve this.
- Fewer nonverbal cues. A therapist sees less body language over video. Good clinicians compensate by checking in more directly about what you're feeling.
- The transition is shorter. In person, the drive home gives you time to process. Online, it helps to build in a few minutes before your next call or task.
How Virtual Couples Therapy Differs from In-Person Sessions
Couples therapy adds a third person to the conversation, and that changes the logistics more than individual therapy does.
Where virtual couples therapy can help
- Easier scheduling. Coordinating two work calendars, childcare and a commute is one of the most common reasons couples delay starting. Video removes much of that.
- Seeing your real patterns. Partners are in their own environment, which can make everyday dynamics easier to notice and work with.
- Flexibility when life changes. Travel or a schedule shift doesn't have to mean cancelling.
Challenges, and how clinicians handle them
- Sharing a screen. Both partners need to be visible. A laptop on a table, not a phone held by one person, works best.
- Heated moments. In an office, a therapist can physically slow things down. Online, clinicians use clear structure, agreed time-outs and more active guidance.
- Privacy at home. Children, roommates or thin walls can make honest conversation harder. Some couples choose in-person sessions for exactly this reason.
Gottman-informed couples work, online and in person
The Gottman Method, developed by Drs. John and Julie Gottman from decades of relationship research, focuses on friendship, managing conflict and creating shared meaning. Assessments, structured exercises and skill practice from Gottman-informed work adapt well to video. Several of Shoreside's couples clinicians use Gottman Method-informed approaches, alongside emotion-focused and attachment-based methods. For a full overview of formats and methods, see our guide to couples and family therapy options in greater Milwaukee.
When couples should start in person or in individual sessions
If either partner feels unsafe, afraid of the other or unable to speak freely, joint sessions at home are not the right starting point. A partner may be listening, or the conversation may continue after the call ends. In those situations, a clinician will typically recommend individual sessions first. Tell your therapist privately during the consultation if this applies to you.
When In-Person Therapy Is the Better Starting Point
Virtual therapy fits many people, but in-person care may be a better first step when:
- You don't have a private, reliable space to talk.
- You're considering an intensive. Shoreside's couples, EMDR and Brainspotting intensives are in person only.
- You're working with a child. Younger clients usually do better in an office, especially with play-based approaches.
- Screens already dominate your day, and you want therapy to feel separate from work.
- You're in an acute crisis. Call or text 988 any time, or call 911 in an emergency. Weekly therapy, in person or online, is not a crisis service.
Many clients mix both: an in-person first session to build rapport, then video when schedules get tight.
Privacy, Security & HIPAA-Compliant Telehealth
Shoreside's virtual sessions run on a HIPAA-compliant telehealth platform. HIPAA is the federal law that sets privacy and security rules for health information. You join through a secure link from your therapist, with no software to download.
Sessions are never recorded. A few practical steps protect your privacy on your end:
- Use a private, closed room or a parked car, and wear headphones.
- Use your own device and a secure Wi-Fi network rather than public Wi-Fi.
- Close other apps and turn off notifications during the session.
Cost, Superbills & Out-of-Network Benefits
Shoreside Therapies is a private-pay, out-of-network practice, and our fees are the same whether you meet in person or online.
| Session | Typical CPT Code | Fee |
|---|---|---|
| Individual, 45 minutes | 90834 (38–52 min psychotherapy) | $200 |
| Individual, 60 minutes | 90837 (53+ min psychotherapy) | $240 |
| Couples session | 90847 (family/couples psychotherapy) | $275 |
A CPT code is the standard billing code insurers use to identify a service. Fees current as of October 2026. See Rates & Insurance for the latest.
Why private pay?
- More privacy. When you pay privately, no diagnosis goes to an insurance company unless you choose to submit a superbill.
- No insurer-imposed session limits. You and your therapist decide how often you meet and for how long.
- Care built around you. Treatment isn't shaped by what a plan will authorize.
Superbills and out-of-network reimbursement
A superbill is an itemized receipt with everything an insurer needs: dates, CPT codes, diagnosis code and your clinician's credentials. If your plan has out-of-network benefits, you can submit it for partial reimbursement, often after you've met your out-of-network deductible.
Reimbursement varies widely by plan, and some plans don't cover couples therapy. Before you start, call your insurer and ask: "What are my out-of-network outpatient mental health benefits, and do I have a deductible?" Shoreside also offers free benefit verification before your first session. Our step-by-step guide to out-of-network therapy and superbills in Wisconsin covers the details.
Using HSA or FSA funds
Therapy is generally an eligible expense for HSA and FSA accounts, so you can pay with pre-tax dollars for either format.
How to Choose: Five Questions to Ask Yourself
- Do I have a private space where I can talk openly for 45–60 minutes?
- What gets in the way of my showing up consistently: travel, childcare, work hours?
- For couples: can we both be on camera together, and do we both feel safe speaking freely?
- Am I interested in an intensive or a specialty that's offered only in person?
- Would I feel more comfortable meeting my therapist face to face first?
There's no wrong answer, and you can change formats later. A free consultation is a good place to talk it through. Comparing a local practice with a national app? Read online couples counseling vs. large telehealth apps.
Therapy with Shoreside: In Milwaukee, Whitefish Bay, Glendale & Online
Shoreside Therapies offers in-person sessions at our Milwaukee, Whitefish Bay and Glendale offices, and online therapy across Wisconsin. Select clinicians are also licensed in Illinois, Indiana, Minnesota and Colorado, and virtual couples therapy is available in Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota and Colorado. For virtual sessions, you need to be physically located in a state where your clinician is licensed at the time of each session.
Our licensed clinicians work with individuals on anxiety, depression, trauma, life transitions and more. For couples, we offer couples therapy and discernment counseling for partners unsure about the future of the relationship. If you're curious where your relationship stands, our article on the 7 stages of relationships is a good place to start.
Not Sure Which Format Fits? Let's Talk.
Book a free 15-minute consultation. We'll talk through what you're looking for, whether in-person or virtual sessions make more sense, and which clinician is a good fit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is online therapy as effective as in-person therapy?
For many common concerns, such as anxiety, depression and stress, research generally finds video therapy produces outcomes comparable to in-person care. The relationship with your therapist and consistent attendance tend to matter more than format. Some services, like intensives, are in person only.
Can couples do therapy online if we're in different locations?
Sometimes. Many couples join from the same room, but partners can join from two locations if both are physically in a state where the clinician is licensed. Shoreside offers virtual couples therapy in Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota and Colorado. Your therapist will discuss what works best during your first session.
Does insurance cover virtual therapy at Shoreside?
Shoreside is out-of-network, so we don't bill insurance directly. You pay at the time of service, and we provide a superbill you can submit for possible out-of-network reimbursement. Coverage varies by plan, and the process is the same for in-person and online sessions.
Can I switch between in-person and online sessions?
Yes, in most cases. Many clients start in person and move to video when schedules get busy, or the reverse. Your therapist will confirm availability at their office location.
Is my virtual session private and secure?
Shoreside uses a HIPAA-compliant video platform, and sessions are never recorded. Privacy on your side matters too: a closed room, headphones and a secure, non-public Wi-Fi connection help keep your session confidential.